Tag: 416 4th Avenue

  • Nature? We Don’t Need No Stinkin’ Nature When There’s Money to Be Made

    the greenspace created by our back yards
    Some of the greenspace created by the individual back yards of our houses.

    WHY DO WE HAVE BACKYARDS?

    Housing designers in 19th century New York City planned houses with backyards that would make a communal greenspace as a reaction to the overcrowding, disease, and pollution of the slums created by the Industrial Revolution. Such open-center blocks maximized sunlight and ventilation to prevent the spread of disease; they were also thought to make urban living less stressful.

    Although the original designers did not have to worry about climate change, the backyards also help to lower the temperature of the neighborhood and absorb excess rainwater. In a sea of concrete and asphalt, these back yards also provide a haven for wildlife like birds, butterflies, squirrels, and the disappearing bees. Real-estate developers don’t care.

    WHAT WILL DIE FOR ANOTHER LUXURY BUILDING?

    Here is just some of the nature that will die so that the rich can enjoy their roof terraces in the sky and in-house wine bars in the planned 85-unit luxury apartment building called the 416 4th Avenue Project. T

    First up is the neighborhood tree, a decades-old apple tree that provides pollen for bees, space for wildlife, and food for the same critters; it will be the first to die because it is in the way of the proposed building.

    A decades-old apple tree in bloom.
    Our decades-old apple tree that will be cut down for the 85-unit luxury housing development.

    Rose of Sharon trees, like these in bloom, grow in many yards, but they will also be ripped out for profit.

    A Rose of Sharon shrub.
    Rose of Sharon shrub that feeds more bees will be removed for a massive building in the greenspace.

    The plants in this garden on 4th Avenue will slowly die from lack of sunlight as the massive luxury apartment building throws neighboring backyards into permanent shade.

    Small space, but full of plants to feed bees and butterflies, cool the air, and absorb rainfall
    A blooming forsythia bush

    Forsythia to brighten the early Spring

    Pink flowers on a bleeding heart plant

    Bleeding heart in bloom sprinkled with petals from the neighboring apple tree

    Rhododendron shrub with yellow blossoms.
    Rhododendron in bloom with hellebores beneath the pot.
    An azalea bush in glorious bloom.
    An azalea bush in full bloom

    All these plants will die- either cut down or dying slowly from lack of sunlight, but not to worry because tech bros paying $10,000/month and more in rent can have barbeques on the roof without ever encountering their neighbors or the wildlife that previouslycalled the greenspace home.

    MORE FLOODING?

    Located in the rainwater flood zone, the greenspace in our block also helps to absorb excess water during rainstorms, preventing nearby floods like the one pictured below; this is a necessary function since the city never built a large-enough sewer system to handle the structures that are already here.

    Flooding on 4th Avenue in 2023
    An example of the flooding on 4th Avenue and Carroll Street from September 2023. Photo by Joann Amitrano.

    WHERE ARE OUR ELECTED REPRESENTATVIES?

    At the same time that the City Council is allowing unfettered construction of luxury housing on 4th Avenue that will replace needed nature on our block, New York City officials say they are desperately trying to create more green space.

    Brooklyn Community Board 6, Council Member Hanif, Mayor Mamdani, please make this make sense. The excuse that “this is legal” doesn’t cut it.